Border Collie vs German Shepherd

Both breeds side by side, to help you choose based on your lifestyle.

Last reviewed: October 7, 2026

Border Collie
Border ColliePhoto: See source page, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
German Shepherd
German ShepherdPhoto: gomagoti, CC BY-SA 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons

Key differences

Detailed comparison

CriterionBorder CollieGerman Shepherd
OriginAnglo-Scottish borderGermany
SizeMediumLarge
Adult weight14–25 kg22–40 kg
Life expectancy12–15 years12–14 years
TemperamentIntense, Smart, EnergeticLoyal, Confident, Intelligent
Energy
Exercise needs
Grooming
Shedding
Family-friendly
With other pets
Apartment-friendly
Trainability
Copes with time alone
Vocal

Weight and life expectancy are typical ranges; individuals vary. 1–5 profiles are PawShorts editorial estimates, not measurements.